Intel(R) Matrix Storage Manager only checks for the integrity of the data being saved, it does not check if the hard drives or hardware are fine. To check the integrity of the discs you will need to check with its respective manufacturer for tools to test them.
Since you have a RAID 1, you can move the RAID arrya to newer hard drives by following the instrcutions on this site:
Keep in mind that Intel(R) Matrix Storage Manager 8.9 is a mature software version which is not longer supported. I suggest you to check with your motherboard manufacturer for an updated version of this software like Intel(R) Rapid Storage Technology.