4 Replies Latest reply on Oct 30, 2010 6:36 AM by Dryne

    eSATA Port on DX58SO

    Dryne

      Hi, Folks.

       

      I have been reading the the eSATA port and controller on this motherboard are unreliable.  I had planned to get a Buffalo Quad raid drives to connect to my desktop, but if the eSATA controller is as poor as I have read, I will not go this route.

       

      Does anyone have any experience good or bad with eSATA for this motherboard?

       

      Thanks.

        • 1. Re: eSATA Port on DX58SO
          Dogwood

          This has been my experience as well. My DX58SO components have been 100% reliable, except for the ESATA ports, which seem flaky. (Also, as I've noted in another thread, the latest BIOS update introduced a problem with RAID support.) I'll mention one example. I've used Clonezilla, which boots off a CD-ROM (and thus doesn't use Windows drivers), to clone an internal disk to a removable drive. When I use the ESATA connection, there are periodic errors, but it's reliable with a USB connection. I've swapped cables and housing, so I'm fairly sure my problem was in the ESATA itself and not the external hardware. As I recall, when I first used ESATA in early 2009, I found it reliable, but later I noticed problems. This made me wonder whether a bug had crept in with a subsequent BIOS update. Anyway, I didn't have an urgent need of ESATA (although of course it's faster than USB), so I just stopped using it, and everything else worked fine.

          1 of 1 people found this helpful
          • 2. Re: eSATA Port on DX58SO
            galbicka

            I have had no problems with the eSata ports on my DX58SO. I use an external dual SATA dock that is plugged in to both ports. I make backup images of my internal drives to external drives by booting from an Acronis TIH 11 CD and have never had an image or disk clone fail yet. I have done many restores from these backups and never had one fail either. However I do seem to have problems with the RAID controller and have quit using it for the time being.

            http://communities.intel.com/message/103453

            1 of 1 people found this helpful
            • 3. Re: eSATA Port on DX58SO
              Dryne

              So...it works for one and does not work good for another.

               

              I'm now leaning toward a Synology DS1010+ disk station.  I can connect this via eSATA or ethernet, so I can try eSATA and switch to NAS in the event it's unreliable as it has been for some.  If RAID is as bad as people have been posting, I may have to stick with ethernet.

               

              Thanks.

              • 4. Re: eSATA Port on DX58SO
                Dryne

                After reading information on NAS boxes available and also the various problems with the Marvel eSATA controller, I decided to go with the QNAP TS-809 Pro.  This box is ethernet only, and so far it has performed impressively well.  NAS + ethernet is much more mature than eSATA, so I decided this route as opposed to making a gamble.

                 

                Thanks for the feedback.