4 Replies Latest reply on Feb 28, 2017 8:24 AM by Intel Corporation

    SSD Intel 730 vs Intel s3510 (Boot time= 2s vs 5s)

    anderson88702

      I was reading Intel specifications for both SSDs.

       

      http://www.intel.com/content/dam/su...ntel_SSD_730_Series_Product_specification.pdf

       

      http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/solid-state-drives/ssd-dc-s3510-spec.html

       

      The 730 has 2s boot time and the s3510s has a 5s boot time.

      (In the PDF its written: Power on to ready , page 9)

       

      That is a lot of difference. What would explain that?

       

      I am not worried about these 3s but if the boot time is so different ,

      other activities may differ a lot too (I am talking about desktop usage, not server ).

       

      I also wanna know if you have any advice against using the s3510 as desktop SSD.

      I want the s3510 because of the Power Loss Protection, but if its slower than the 730

      I may change my choice to the 730.. Is the s3510 slower? How much ?

      (talking about desktop usage )

       

      thx in advance.

        • 1. Re: SSD Intel 730 vs Intel s3510 (Boot time= 2s vs 5s)
          Intel Corporation
          This message was posted on behalf of Intel Corporation

          Hello anderson88702,

          We understand that you're looking to buy a new Intel® SSD and would like some assistance comparing models.

          A good place to start would be by clarifying that Data Center drives are not all inherently faster than the Consumer family drives. Each model is built with a different application in mind, some are built for speed, other focus more on endurance or power efficiency.

          The Intel® SSD 730 Series has a faster performance (and boot time). But the Intel® SSD DC S3510 Series has over double the Endurance Rating (lifetime writes). The 730 Series is also the oldest of the two, having been first released in 2014. 

          While a Data Center drive is usually overkill for desktop application, as most modern consumer drives will greatly out-live their 5 year warranty period, there shouldn't be any compatibility issues because you're still purchasing a SATA SSD. 

          Now, for a newer drive that is faster than both, you may also want to look at the Intel® SSD 540s Series. You can see my comparison of the three models, or create your own in our Product Specifications page:

          - http://ark.intel.com/compare/94209,81039,86197

          To compare our drives side by side, you may want to visit our Help Me Choose page. In this page you will be able to separate our drives by family and form factor. Each list is organized by release date.

          We hope this information helps. Please let us know if anything was not clear or if you have further questions.

          Best regards,
          Carlos A.

          2 of 2 people found this helpful
          • 2. Re: SSD Intel 730 vs Intel s3510 (Boot time= 2s vs 5s)
            anderson88702

            Thanks for your answer but the 540 doesnt have enhanced power loss protection.

            And a UPS pure sine wave here in my country cost 600 dollars, so I am thinking about buying the s3510(240gb) because of the power loss protection.

            So I still wanna know how much slower is the s3510 compared to the 730 or the 540s considering desktop usage only .

            There isnt much review/test about the s3510 and the  ones that I found analyze its behavior in a server enviroment only.

            Even the Intel Comparison table isnt very clear because it shows the IOPS 100% Span for the s3510

            and 8 GB span for the 730 and 540.

            • 3. Re: SSD Intel 730 vs Intel s3510 (Boot time= 2s vs 5s)
              Intel Corporation
              This message was posted on behalf of Intel Corporation

              Hello anderson88702,

              Comparing a consumer drive against a data center drive is often not as simple as comparing two drives that belong to the same family. Since both are intended for different markets entirely, the tests are ran and displayed differently. However, between these particular two, the S3510 may just be the better choice.

              Benefits of the Intel® SSD DC S3510 Series:

              - Enhanced Power-Loss Data Protection.
              - End-to-End Data Protection
              - Higher endurance rating.
              - Smaller Lithography Type/newer model.
              - Usually sells at a lower price.
              - More available capacity models (from 80GB up to 1.6TB)

              Benefits of the Intel® SSD 730 Series:

              - Slightly faster sequential read/write speeds (only about 30-50 MB/s faster)
              - Slightly faster start up time.
              - Compatible with Intel® RST
              - Available in two capacities (240 and 480GB)

              If you're interested in learning more about the Enhanced Power-Loss Data Protection feature, you may like the following articles, this feature was previously refered to as PLI:

              - Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology Brief.
              - Enhanced power-loss data protection in the Intel® Solid-State Drive 320 Series (Written for a different model, but explains how the technology works, applies to all models).

              Best regards,
              Carlos A.

              2 of 2 people found this helpful
              • 4. Re: SSD Intel 730 vs Intel s3510 (Boot time= 2s vs 5s)
                Intel Corporation
                This message was posted on behalf of Intel Corporation

                Hello anderson88702,

                We're following up on your thread since we have not heard back from you.

                If you have any questions or need further assistance, please let us know.

                Best regards,
                Carlos A.