4 Replies Latest reply on Feb 3, 2010 10:01 AM by martymonster

    Problem with S5500BC

    martymonster

      I purchased this board last year along with (mid Oct 2010)

      E5520 Xeon and fan

      SC5650DP case

      Seagate hard disc - on certified list

      4 x Kingstom 2GB memory - Intel certified KVR1066D3D8R7SK2/4GI) total 8GB

       

      When the parts arrived, the memory which was sent was NOT certified but it was installed anyway.

       

      When booting, the board always gave 3 short quick beeps.

      I ram Memtest 86+ for  many hours without a problem.

      Then on 30 Oct 2009 the server rebooted with

       

      Num :  585

      Time Stamp :  10/30/2009-16:27:28

      Sensor Type, Name and Number :  Memory /Mmry ECC Sensor (#0x02)

      Event Description :  CRITICAL event: Mmry ECC Sensor reports uncorrectable error. There has been an uncorrectable ECC or other uncorrectable memory error for the memory module DIMM =  A1.

      Generator ID :  SMI Handler (Channel #00h)

       

      and on Nov 9th

       

      Num :  1228

      Time Stamp :  11/09/2009-14:06:47

      Sensor Type, Name and Number :  Memory /Mmry ECC Sensor (#0x02)

      Event Description :  CRITICAL event: Mmry ECC Sensor reports uncorrectable error. There has been an uncorrectable ECC or other uncorrectable memory error for the memory module DIMM =  A1.

      Generator ID :  SMI Handler (Channel #00h)

       

      That memory was returned and the correct Intel certified Kingston 2GB (4 off) was sent. 10th Dec 2009

      This memory was installed, but the bios still always gives those 3 beeps when powering up.

       

      Memtest 86+ was run for 24 hours without error.

       

      I contacted Intel via phone and the support person told me that those 3 short beeps were normal and NOT an indication of a memory error.

       

      For a few weeks I could not do much testing due to family health resons.

       

      For the past few weeks I have been able to do some testing.

       

      The OS installed is Win 2008 Server R2 which runs a few virtual machines.

      Twice when one of the virtual machines (XP Pro) was running Folding @ Home the complete system rebooted (Blue screen of death on Win 2008 R2)).

       

      Then on 27th Jan 2010 the following occured

      Num :  1936

      Time Stamp :  01/27/2010-20:06:52

      Sensor Type, Name and Number :  Memory /Mmry ECC Sensor (#0x02)

      Event Description :  CRITICAL event: Mmry ECC Sensor reports uncorrectable error. There has been an uncorrectable ECC or other uncorrectable memory error for the memory module DIMM =  A2.

      Generator ID :  SMI Handler (Channel #00h)

       

      I do not feel that there is an actual problem with the memory but more of a problem with the Ram slots on the motherboard.

      I have tried the memory using 1 stick at a time, 2 sticks at a time etc but it still gives 3 short quick beeps from the bios when booting.

       

      Does anyone have an idea whether this is a problem with the S5500BC board and should I have it returned under RMA?

       

      Martin

        • 1. Re: Problem with S5500BC
          edwardzh

          What is the memory model you actually installed? It DOES look like memory issue. And what Intel support person told you was true - the three short beeps are normal during POST. Instead, three long beeps indicates memory error, and if you got that beep most likely you won't get display on screen.

           

          Btw how did you populate your DIMMs? Suppose you have two processors and four DIMMs, you should populate slots A1, B1, D1 and E1 (all blue slots).     

          • 2. Re: Problem with S5500BC
            martymonster

            Hi,

            As my initial post stated

             

            I purchased this board last year along with (mid Oct 2010)

            E5520 Xeon and fan

            SC5650DP case

            Seagate hard disc - on certified list

            4 x Kingstom 2GB memory - Intel certified KVR1066D3D8R7SK2/4GI) total 8GB

             

            The above states E5520 CPU which is a single CPU.

            The memory was also listed as above.

            The RAM is installed in A and B as there is only ONE CPU.

            • 3. Re: Problem with S5500BC
              edwardzh

              I see... I'd suggest you swap DIMM slots to isolate the error. Also, please update BIOS/BMC firmware if you haven't done so.

              • 4. Re: Problem with S5500BC
                martymonster

                Hi,

                The system stopped again yesterday morning with an ECC error in DIMM A1.

                So far, it has stopped with ECC errors in DIMM A1 and DIMM A2 with both certified and Non-certified RAM.

                 

                I have just now swapped A1 with B1 and A2 with B2.

                 

                I note that the system gives 3 beeps when the USB keyboard and USB mouse are plugged in but gives 2 beeps when they are both unplugged.

                 

                Martin