Home > Intel Communities > Open Port IT Community > The Server Room > Blog > Authors > Dave Hill

The Server Room Blog

7 Posts authored by: Dave Hill
2

If you hadn’t heard, Microsoft* and Intel spent a lot of effort optimizing Windows* Server 2008 R2 (and Windows 7) to improve energy efficiency by reducing system power consumption at idle and under load.  For more details, check out the presentation from the Intel Developer Forum a few weeks ago titled Microsoft and Intel: Innovations in Hardware and Software to Help Deliver New Technology Experiences.  This presentation (and other IDF presentations) can be found at intel.com/go/idfsessions (search for SPCS003 using the session ID number).  There is good information on the operating system optimizations that were done to reduce power consumption.  Slide 22 has an excellent comparison of the power consumption of Windows Server 2003 vs. Windows Server 2008 R2 running on the same Xeon® 5500 series processors. It shows that using WinSrv2008 R2 reduced system idle and peak power consumption by ~60W!!  In addition, Hyper-V* 1.1 now uses the power management features of Intel processors to reduce power consumption during periods of low utilization.  

This is a great time to show your customers the energy efficiency benefits that come with upgrading to WinSrv2008 R2 at the same time they refresh their server infrastructure with Xeon® 5500 based servers.

 

*Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others

2 Comments Permalink
4

Did you know that many electrical utility companies are offering rebates for companies that purchase energy efficient IT equipment such as servers, PCs and power management software?

Why are utilities doing this? Today’s high cost of energy and the availability of Federal stimulus dollars for energy efficiency programs are making this an ideal time for utilities to offer customers incentives for investing in energy efficient computers and servers. Federal agencies are directing funds to utilities to support these incentives.  Also, state legislation often requires many utilities to devote a portion of revenues to fund energy efficiency programs, including encouraging the purchase of energy efficient IT equipment such as servers, PCs, and power management software.

In the United States, there are currently 20+ utilities that are offering rebate incentives for the purchase energy efficient IT equipment with another 70+ utilities considering or in the process of rolling out a rebate program. Here’s a list of utilities that we know of (as of July ’09).

 

          Arizona Public Service Company

          Austin  Energy

          Avista

          BC Hydro (Vancouver, BC)

          Bonneville Power Administration

          Energy Trust of Oregon

          Idaho Power

          Los Angeles Department of Water & Power

          Manitoba Hydro

          Northeast Utilities

          Oncor Energy

          Pacific Gas and Electric

          Sacramento Muni Utility District

          San Diego Gas and Electric

          Seattle City Light

          Silicon Valley Power

          Snohomish PUD

          Southern California Edison

In addition to the savings that can be achieved just by consolidating multiple older servers with newer Xeon® 5500 (Nehalem) servers, getting additional cash back from the utility companies can make the decision to refresh your server infrastructure that much more lucrative.

Let me know if you are aware of other rebate or incentive programs offered by your utility company (U.S. or another country).

4 Comments Permalink
0

Did you know that using an electricity rate of 11.4 cents per kWh provides a simple method of calculating annual electricity cost of any device?

 

1 watt of power consumption, with an electricity rate of 11.4 cents per kWh, cost $1 per year, assuming power usage remains constant.  Also, as a general rule of thumb, every 1W of device power consumption in a data center requires an additional 1 watt for overhead power (Source: Intel IT). So a device that consumes 1W actually consumes 2W of power at a data center level.


Here's the math:  1 Watt power * 8760 hours per year / 1000 * $0.114 electricity rate per kWh = $1 per year.  This math holds the same for any currency, Euro, Yuan, etc.  11.4 cents per kWh is the crossover point…and as electricity rates increase over 11.4 cents, 1 watt will cost more than a $1 per year. 

The datacenter overhead power, often referred to as Power Usage Effectiveness (PUE) is a number which has emerged as the leading metric for data center energy efficiency.


You might say that 1W = $2 annually doesn't sound like much, but start doing the math for 1000 servers that consume 200W in a data center with a PUE of 2.0 which works out to annual electricity cost of ~$400,000 per year.  Now, for every 1 watt the server power consumption is reduced, this would translate into $2000 annual savings.  Note, this is a very rudimentary example, but it is useful to illustrate why customers are really starting to focus on power as one of their key purchase decisions.

    

If you need energy efficient servers, there are multiple server vendors currently have some exceptional energy efficient products based on Intel(R) Xeon(R) 5500 processors.  And looking forward, we are also actively working on how to reduce power of the processor and at the system level for the upcoming generations of products.


Here’s some good reference on electricity rates:

For United States, state by state electricity rate comparison

For Europe, 1st half of 2008 rate comparison by country.


Remember, power is one purchase decision, but it is not the only one.  A rack of servers that consumes less power that does less work isn't an efficient way of deploying servers either.  Ensure that the performance vector is considered.  Intel® Xeon® 5500 processor based servers provid exceptional performance and perf/watt leadership over the competition.


Quick question for you:  How does electricity rate of 11.4 cents per kWh and a data center PUE of 2.0 compare to your data center? 

 

 

0 Comments Permalink
1

If your company needs new servers, this is a great time to be in the market.  Intel based Xeon® 5500 (Nehalem) servers that were introduced only a month ago have been arriving at customer sites all over the world and they provide some very compelling performance and energy efficiency benefits.  Here are 3 key items to consider before buying your next server.  The actual order of importance of these items may vary depending upon your business needs.

1.  Performance.  This is still a primary reason why new servers are purchased.  The best way to measure performance is to actually run your applications on the server you are considering.  If that is not possible or feasible, the next best choice is to compare server performance using a suite of benchmarks.  Some of the more common benchmarks that IT departments use to compare server performance are:

a.       Virtualization performance using Vmware VMmark: http://www.vmware.com/products/vmmark/results.html

b.      Energy efficiency using SPECpower_ssj2008: http://www.spec.org/power_ssj2008/

c.       Integer performance using SPECing_rate_base2006: http://www.spec.org/cpu2006/results/cpu2006.html#SPECint_rate

d.      Floating point performance using SPECfp_rate_base2006: http://www.spec.org/cpu2006/results/cpu2006.html#SPECfp_rate

e.       Web server performance using SPECweb2005: http://www.spec.org/web2005/results/

f.        Java performance using SPECjbb2005: http://www.spec.org/jbb2005/results/jbb2005.html

After looking these benchmark results, one thing you’ll notice is the Xeon® 5500 processors provide phenomenal performance…often up to 2x the previous generation!

2.   Server Hardware Choices 

a.       Processor.  The processor is one of the most important choices in the server.  Performance, features, power envelope and price all need to be considered.  From a power perspective, there are three power envelopes available for Xeon® 5500 server processors (95W, 80W and 60W).  In addition, there are 130W Xeon® 5500 processors, but these are primarily being used for workstations.  If you are in constrained power environment, it may be worthwhile to consider buying a lower power processor to reduce energy consumption.  Depending upon the processor SKU you are interested in, it is possible to get the exact same performance/frequency with a processor that just consumes less power.  (i.e. Xeon L5520 2.26GHz 60W instead of the Xeon E5520 2.26GHz 80W).  The L in front of the processor number refers to low voltage processors that consume less power.   

b.      Power supply.  Choosing a power supply with a high efficiency rating is one of the easiest choices you can make to reduce power consumption.  Choose a power supply that is at least 80%+ or higher efficiency.  Some of the newer power supplies are 90%+ or higher.  The higher the percentage, the better.

c.       Memory.  Every DIMM installed in the server consumes power.  In general, the fewer the DIMMs used, the less power that server will consume.  For a given memory capacity, such as 24GB, choose six 4GB DIMMs instead of twelve 2GB DIMMs.  The price of 2GB and 4GB DIMMs are almost at price per bit parity, but the power consumption of the memory will be much less with fewer DIMMs installed. 

d.      Add in boards.  Compare power consumption of add in boards such as 10GbE adapters, fibre channel adapters and other I/O cards.  Also, do you really need a fibre channel card these days.  FCOE (Fibre Channel over Ethernet) using a 10GbE adaptor is definitely a cost effective and power efficient way to get access to your storage array.

3.       To virtualize or not to virtualize?  Virtualization is no longer just a buzz word.  Virtualization is being used by many companies across multiple diverse industries today.  Fundamentally, it is an excellent way to consolidate many applications onto a single server, thereby increasing the utilization, value and energy efficiency of every server purchased.  Definetely a top item to consider.

What about your business?  What items do you consider before purchasing servers to maximize energy efficient performance?

1 Comments Permalink
3

The Intel® Xeon® 5500 Series Processor (aka Nehalem) officially stepped out from behind the curtain onto center stage today.  This processor is an engineering marvel…one that can intelligently provide phenomenal performance on demand, while also sipping power when not in use.

Any measure of energy efficiency consists of performance in conjunction with the amount power consumed, so let’s cover these “big” items first.

  • Performance:  As of March 30, 2009, Intel based 2 socket Xeon® 5500 series servers set at least 30 world performance records across a wide range of benchmarks that cover virtually every application type on the market. The performance results, just by themselves, are utterly amazing, and in general they are greater than 2x the Intel® Xeon® 5400 series processors (Harpertown).
  • System level power consumption:  The electricity bill is based on how much power the server consumes, so that is also an important part of the energy efficiency equation. In general, Intel® Xeon® 5500 (Nehalem) based servers consume equal or slightly less power under peak workloads vs. previous generation Intel® Xeon® 5400 based servers.  By increasing performance more than 2x over previous Intel server processors while keeping overall power consumption in check, this is a great recipe for energy efficient performance.  In addition, when servers are at idle or are not fully utilized, customers want them to consume the least amount of power possible. Because of some key new power management features built into Nehalem, system idle power is dramatically lower (up to 50% less) than previous generation Intel® Xeon® 5400 based servers.

Now let’s get into three of the “behind the curtain” details of how some of the energy efficiency improvements are achieved.

  1. Power gating:  When a core is inactive, the operating system can request the core to enter a deep C state. Xeon® 5500 series processors supports C6, which is called “power gating”. This essentially puts the core into such a low power state that it consumes very close to 0W when not in use.
  2. DIMM memory power management: Today’s servers often have a lot of DIMMs installed, but leaving them in their full power state all the time isn’t a very wise. The Xeon® 5500 processor can intelligently reduce DIMM power consumption when not active by using techniques such as clock gating (CKE) and putting the DIMMs in “sleep state”, called self-refresh.
  3. Increased # of performance states:  P-states enable the server to proportionally match the power consumption of the server to the desired performance output. For example, if the processor CPU utilization is less, the operating system may request a lower P-state. By doing this, the power consumption of the processor is reduced to match the lower performance required. All this happens dynamically and allows the processor to scale both performance and power up and down to intelligently meet the workload demands.

In summary, while it is interesting to get into these “behind the curtain details”, what matters most is the performance and power at a system level. Servers based on Intel® Xeon® 5500 Series Processors represent a quantum leap forward in terms of both performance and energy efficiency! Call up your favorite server vendor and “test drive” one today to see for yourself.  And…once you get your hands on one, let me know what you think.

3 Comments Permalink
0

Only a few years ago, customers seldom considered server energy efficiency when buying servers. Today, server energy efficiency is often one of the key purchase criteria. And for some customers, energy efficient performance is the #1 criteria. Going forward in time, it is expected that the majority of people will use energy efficient performance (sometimes referred to as performance/watt) when evaluating servers.

From a customer point of view, the request is simple: "I want both high performance and reduced power consumption…at the same time." From a product design viewpoint, the "opportunity" to reduce power while still improving performance comes with some unique tradeoffs that are often complex. How much performance is needed? How much can/should power consumption be reduced? If power consumption is reduced, what impact will that have on performance? Etc, etc.

Processor design cycles are quite long and are started many years before a product actually comes to market. Because of the long design cycle, there is comprehensive process at the beginning to determine product features based on expected market needs. At the time the Nehalem architecture was being developed, customers were just starting to evaluate servers based energy efficient performance, but the Nehalem processor design team decided to make energy efficiency a fundamental "feature" of the processor. The good news is the team correctly predicted the market requirements with the upcoming Intel® Xeon® 5500 Processors (aka. Nehalem). Servers based on Nehalem processors are expected to provide customers with exactly what they have been requesting…"knock your socks off" performance along with reduced power consumption.

As Wayne Gretzky once famously said: “A good hockey player plays where the puck is. A great hockey player plays where the puck is going to be.” With Nehalem, Intel is definitely skating to where the puck will be.

0 Comments Permalink
1

The Intel® Xeon® 7400 Processor was officially announced just a few weeks ago and there has been phenomonal interest in this product because of it's world record breaking performance leadership as well as it's great energy efficiency.

 

Let's first discuss one of the primary advantages of the Intel® Xeon® 7400 Processor: Up to 50% better performance/watt and up to 10% less system power vs. 7300. As stated, this is pretty straightforward: Intel has real world results that show significant performance increases while consuming less power as compared to servers based on the previous generation Intel® Xeon(R) 7300 Processors. The performance increase can largely be attributed to designing the Xeon® 7400 processor with 6 cores based on the Intel® Core™ Microarchitecture. In addition, the primary reason for the power decrease is because Xeon® 7400 uses the latest 45nm High-K process technology instead of 65nm in the previous generation. In general, processors based on the 45nm process consume less power than the processor's rated TDP (thermal design power) value. It must be noted that power consumption can vary by processor and some processors may consume even less power and others may consume up to the processor's rated TDP value. For more details on both the performance and power, I recommend taking a look at this 3rd party review by Anandtech*: http://it.anandtech.com/IT/showdoc.aspx?i=3414&p=1

 

Next, let's discuss the positive impact these servers can have on your data center. Whether you have an existing data center or plan to build a new one, there is always a fixed amount of power that is provided to that data center. Energy efficient performance, in it's simplest definition, is the ratio of performance in relation to the amount of power consumed. The higher the ratio, the more energy efficient your data center is. To accomplish this, two vectors need to be considered. The first is performance output and the second is power consumption (both when servers are operating at peak performance and when they are running at lower utilization levels or at idle). Servers based on the Intel® Xeon® 7400 processor can provide both higher performance as well as lower power, which offer some very compelling energy efficiency benefits. For example, when using virtualization multiple applications that currently run on independent servers can be consolidated on fewer, higher performing servers, while still providing performance headroom for future growth. By doing this, both acquisition and ongoing electricity/operational costs can be dramatically reduced. To see how much money you can potentially save by upgrading to servers based on the Intel® Xeon® 7400 processor, take a look at the ROI using the Intel® Xeon® Server Estimator at www.intel.com/go/xeonestimator

 

In summary, the best energy efficient performance can achieved using servers with Intel® Xeon® 7400 Processors. These servers provide both exceptional performance across a wide range of applications, with headroom to grow, while at the same time consuming less power as compared to previous generation Intel 7300 based servers.

 

-


  • Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others.

 

1 Comments Permalink

Filter Blog

By author: By date: By tag: